Max Pemberton’s recent Channel 4 documentary set out with a clear agenda: to frame ADHD as a social construct and a product of modern over-diagnosis. Yet, even with hand-picked experts and selective editing, the narrative fell apart under its own contradictions. The film inadvertently proved that ADHD is a genuine neurodevelopmental condition - one that leaves people struggling within rigid, poorly adapted systems - before hastily pivoting back to calling it a myth.
As professional ADHD coaches and course leaders who have worked with thousands of ADHD adults, we found the program utterly imbalanced, deeply disappointing and potentially dangerous.
The journalism relied on loaded, sensationalist language, describing prescribed medication as "mind-altering amphetamines," "coshes," or comparing treatment to "cocaine." It conflated a historically low diagnosis rate with a low prevalence of the condition. Millions of adults - particularly women and girls, who were entirely ignored in the piece - grew up without a diagnosis because their struggles were missed, not because their ADHD didn't exist. Research consistently shows that ADHD remains underdiagnosed, not overdiagnosed.
Leading experts in the field were either absent or selectively edited. Professor Katya Rubia has since publicly withdrawn her support for the program after her contributions were cherry-picked to fit a pre-determined narrative. Furthermore, dismissing ADHD because there is no single biological test is absurd; by that logic, we would have to declare autism and dyslexia myths as well.
The program’s stance on medication was privileged and out of touch. Lifestyle adjustments, diet, and mindfulness are valuable for everyone, but they are not a "cure." We have always advocated that medication is just one tool among many. However, most people do not have the luxury of redesigning their workplaces or schools to fit their brains. For many, properly titrated medication - which evidence shows helps up to 80% of those prescribed - is the bridge that enables them to stay in education, keep a job and protect their mental health.
Pemberton gave a highly misrepresentative portrayal of seemingly gaining a diagnosis and medication through a tickbox exercise, when the real process takes hours of careful interviewing, gathering a range of evidence and assessing personal impact, ruling out other conditions. Highlighting the management of his own ADHD-like traits through self-built systems, he missed the core diagnostic criteria: significant impairment. People do not seek a diagnosis on a whim or to collect labels. They seek it after years of struggling, shedding shame, and searching for answers. Not everyone wants medication; many simply want to understand how their brains work.
Perhaps the most absurd moment was the performative outrage over the DSM-5 being larger than its earlier editions - as if medical manuals aren't supposed to expand as science advances.
The true danger of this program is its real-world fallout. We are already hearing from many individuals whose colleagues and family members feel emboldened to question their diagnosis or deny them reasonable adjustments.
If Pemberton and his panel truly believe the system needs fixing rather than the individual, they should campaign for inclusive education, workplace accommodations and accessible NHS assessments. Saying society needs to adapt is fine - now let’s see the action. ADHD brains process the world differently, and invalidating their lived reality does nothing to fix the broken environments around them.
Carol, Wennie and Clair
Co-Directors, Procrastination Station CIC
